News · · 3 min read
SRA competence consultation: can your juniors explain AI work?
The SRA is consulting until 3 December 2026 on AI within the Statement of Solicitor Competence, so firms should test whether juniors can verify and explain AI-assisted work.
What happened
A commentary in Legal Futures by Tsipursky argues that a polished AI-assisted argument tells a firm little until the solicitor who produced it can explain which authority supports it, how it applies and where the analysis might fail. A firm that cannot answer those questions, the piece says, is taking an avoidable risk, even when its AI policy looks impressive.
The timing is tied to the Solicitors Regulation Authority. According to the article, its consultation opened on 8 October and runs until 3 December 2026. It proposes updating the Statement of Solicitor Competence to address technology and AI in research, drafting, professional judgment and supervision. The SRA favours embedding AI within existing competences rather than creating a standalone technology competence. These are proposals, with final versions expected in April 2027, and they are not yet binding rules.
The commentary also revisits a case Legal Futures reported on 26 May. A junior solicitor at Pinsent Masons used AI to help draft misleading letters to the High Court. The judge examined a conversation in which the AI supplied wrong or misleading legal material, while the lawyers reviewing the letters failed to catch the problem. The firm self-reported to the SRA. The article adds that in August the SRA warned firms about inaccurate AI-generated court material and confidentiality risks, and reiterated that solicitors and firms remain responsible for competent service and effective supervision.
What it means for solicitors and supervisors
The article's central point is that the case exposed two weaknesses at once: the user's verification and the supervisors' oversight. A written instruction to check AI output may help set expectations, but a firm still needs evidence that its people can do the checking.
The author suggests a practical exercise taking roughly half an hour. A junior is given a short AI-assisted memorandum containing a sound point of law, a plausible but unsupported proposition and a genuine ambiguity, and is asked for a corrected memo with an explanation of the changes. Three abilities are scored separately.
The first is source verification: locating the primary legislation or judgment, identifying the relevant passage, checking that it remains authoritative and showing exactly which proposition it supports. The article stresses that this needs an independent route to the source, because a second AI-generated summary of the first is no substitute for checking the authority itself.
The second is legal reasoning: explaining why the authority applies to these facts, which distinction could change the outcome and what an opposing lawyer might argue. The article notes that accurate quotations can still be assembled into a misleading conclusion.
The third is escalation. Given one fact that makes the apparent answer uncertain, does the junior identify the uncertainty, state what additional information is needed and seek supervision before giving a client or court an unsupported assurance? In the article's words, confident language should never be mistaken for confidence justified by evidence.
For supervising lawyers, the practical reading is that evidence of what people can actually do may matter as much as the policy document.
Where Counsel AI fits
Counsel AI's drafts and first reads cite the section of legislation they rely on, so the reviewer has a named provision to open and read in the primary source rather than a bare conclusion.
That does not remove the need for the checks described above. A citation is a starting point for verification, and the reasoning and escalation steps remain with the solicitor and their supervisor. Counsel AI is software, not a law firm, and the professional judgment stays with the people using it.
Questions
Are the SRA's AI competence proposals already in force?
No. According to Legal Futures, the consultation runs from 8 October to 3 December 2026, final versions are expected in April 2027, and the proposals are not yet new binding rules.
Does the SRA propose a separate technology competence?
According to the article, the SRA favours embedding AI within existing competences rather than creating a standalone technology competence.
How does Counsel AI help with checking citations?
Its drafts and first reads cite the section of legislation they rely on, giving the reviewer a provision to check in the primary source. The checking itself remains the solicitor's responsibility.
Sources
- The AI competence test every junior solicitor should pass · legalfutures.co.uk, 17 Nov 2026
- Counsel AI: /, read 17 Nov 2026
Run a free check, or try every workflow for 14 days
Start