News · · 2 min read
High Court lets litigants in person recover AI research costs
A High Court judge allowed two litigants in person to recover £1,488 for an AI research subscription, applying the usual disbursement test and not treating such costs as automatically recoverable.
What happened
According to Legal Futures, a High Court judge has allowed successful litigants in person to recover the £1,488 cost of a subscription to an AI legal research tool. Mr Justice Sweeting said the subscription made "a real contribution to the proper presentation" of their case. He also stressed that the ruling does not mean such subscriptions will automatically be recoverable in similar cases.
The appellants were pensioners in their 70s who had successfully appealed a suspended possession order obtained by Wargrave on Thames Housing Association. The parties agreed the order could not stand and that the appellants were entitled to costs. The subscription was one disputed element of the consequentials ruling, and there was no direct authority on whether a litigant in person could recover such expenditure.
Sweeting J rejected the argument that the subscription was a payment for legal services under CPR 46.5, which deals with costs payable to litigants in person. He described it instead as expenditure incurred by the appellants in carrying out their own legal work. The remaining question was whether it could be treated as a recoverable disbursement.
What it means for the reader
The judge held that the AI element did not create a new category of disbursement. The usual test applied: whether the expenditure should properly be characterised as a disbursement and, if so, whether it was reasonably and proportionately incurred for the purpose of conducting the litigation. Legal Futures reports that this matches the approach taken to other technological developments, such as electronic disclosure platforms and document management systems.
The housing association had argued that recovery would be an "unwarranted extension" of recoverable litigation expense. The judge allowed the item. He said it would be "an odd outcome" if legal professionals could use their standing artificial intelligence resources in litigation while litigants in person were, in effect, precluded from similar tools.
The facts mattered. According to the report, the appellants did not use a general or free LLM. They bought a subscription giving access to a sector specific AI agent, and used it to prepare arguments and identify relevant authorities. The judge described their written and oral submissions as careful, reasonably focused and ultimately successful on the principal issue. He said the recoverability of such expenditure will depend on the circumstances of the individual case, and Legal Futures describes the matter as fact-specific.
Where Counsel AI fits
The subscription in the case was used to identify relevant authorities. For a firm using AI, that raises an ordinary supervision question: can the person reviewing the work see what it rests on?
Counsel AI's drafts and first reads cite the section of legislation they rely on. A reviewing solicitor can therefore go straight to the cited provision and check it, rather than taking a conclusion on trust. This does not remove the need for judgement, and Counsel AI is software, not a law firm.
The tool in the case was not named. The decision concerns costs recovery by litigants in person, and it leaves open how a similar claim would fare on different facts.
Questions
Does the ruling make AI subscriptions always recoverable?
No. According to Legal Futures, Mr Justice Sweeting said it did not mean such subscriptions would automatically be recoverable. He said recoverability depends on the circumstances of the individual case, and the report describes the matter as fact-specific.
What test did the court apply to the subscription?
The usual disbursement test: whether the expenditure should properly be characterised as a disbursement and whether it was reasonably and proportionately incurred for the purpose of conducting the litigation.
Did the court treat the subscription as a payment under CPR 46.5?
No. Sweeting J rejected the argument that it was a payment for legal services within CPR 46.5 and treated it as expenditure on the appellants' own legal work.
Sources
- Court allows successful LiPs to recover cost of AI legal research tool · legalfutures.co.uk, 20 Nov 2026
- Counsel AI: /, read 20 Nov 2026
Run a free check, or try every workflow for 14 days
Start