News · · 3 min read
DPP Law loses appeal against £60,000 data breach fine
A tribunal upheld a £60,000 fine on DPP Law, saying reliance on specialist suppliers did not excuse a lack of understanding or assessment of risks, and finding the firm's infringements negligent.
What happened
A law firm fined £60,000 for a significant data breach has failed in its appeal against the penalty, according to Legal Futures. The tribunal said the deterrent element of the figure was justified.
The firm, DPP Law, has five offices in Merseyside, Birmingham and London. A cyber-attack in early June 2022 saw highly sensitive details of 682 clients published on the dark web. DPP only became aware when the National Crime Agency contacted it, and it did not notify what is now called the Information Commission until 43 days after the attack.
The attack targeted an administrator account for a legacy case management system. That system was taken out of service in 2019 but remained operational because of a six-year data retention policy. The account had been set up in 2001 and had unrestricted access across the network, but DPP did not know the password and could not reset it.
DPP appealed both the amount and the calculation of the fine. The general regulatory chamber of the First-tier Tribunal found that the Information Commission had correctly applied the five-step approach to calculating a penalty.
What the tribunal said
The tribunal found that DPP "failed to implement appropriate technical and organisational measures to protect the personal data it processed". In particular, it said, the firm failed to maintain effective arrangements for reviewing administrative accounts, limiting their privileges and assessing whether their continued operation remained necessary and secure.
On notification, the tribunal said DPP "could not have been unaware" of its obligation to report the breach promptly under article 33(1) of the GDPR, and that its infringements were negligent. The nature of the data was a "highly relevant factor". The firm processed special category data, including allegations of criminal offences.
Three points may matter to other firms. Being a small firm with limited in-house IT capability "did not lessen the seriousness" of the omission. The tribunal did not consider it sufficient to argue that most of the stolen material was published in an encrypted form. And it said: "We do not consider that DPP's reliance on specialist suppliers excuses the lack of understanding of potential risks or appropriate assessment of them."
What it means for solicitors and practice managers
The tribunal said that having corrected its systems did not reflect the risk that other firms may be relying heavily on external suppliers for security. The penalty needs to be sufficient to incentivise those firms, as well as DPP, to consider and assess the risks of such arrangements.
For a firm's management, the practical questions follow from the tribunal's own wording. Are administrative accounts reviewed and their privileges limited? Is every retained system still needed, and is it still secure? Who decides whether a suspected breach must be reported, and how quickly?
The same reasoning is worth applying to any tool that touches client material, including AI drafting and review software. That is our reading of the decision rather than something the tribunal said about AI. This article explains a news report and is not a substitute for professional guidance on your own obligations.
Where Counsel AI fits
Nothing here should be read as saying Counsel AI secures a firm's network or settles its supplier assessments. Those remain the firm's responsibility.
Counsel AI's drafts and first reads cite the section of legislation they rely on. In our view, that lets the solicitor reviewing a draft go to the provision and check it, and gives them something specific to verify.
The tribunal's message about suppliers is that reliance on them does not excuse a lack of understanding or assessment of the risks. In our view, a tool that shows its working fits with that, and the firm still decides what it is satisfied with.
Questions
Why did DPP Law's appeal fail?
The First-tier Tribunal found that the Information Commission had correctly applied the five-step approach to calculating the penalty, and that the deterrent element of the £60,000 figure was justified.
Did being a small firm reduce the seriousness of the breach?
No. According to Legal Futures, the tribunal said that DPP being a small firm with limited in-house IT capability did not lessen the seriousness of the omission to reassess security.
Does Counsel AI make a firm compliant with data protection rules?
No. Counsel AI's drafts and first reads cite the section of legislation they rely on, which in our view gives a reviewing solicitor something specific to check. Network security and breach reporting remain the firm's responsibility.
Sources
- Law firm fails in appeal against £60k fine for major data breach · legalfutures.co.uk, 20 Nov 2026
- Counsel AI: /, read 22 Nov 2026
Run a free check, or try every workflow for 14 days
Start