News · · 3 min read
Court finds law firm negligent after a deleted line left a charge with no sum
A Manchester firm must pay £100,000 plus interest after a partner deleted the secured sum from a draft charge, a reminder that every edit to a document needs a second look.
What happened
According to Legal Futures, a Manchester law firm, Ratio Law, has been ordered to pay damages of £100,000 plus interest to a former client, MPP (Services) Ltd. His Honour Judge Stephen Davies, sitting as a High Court judge in Manchester, found that co-founder Gisela Alberici "was not really interested in or paying any attention to the details" of the matter.
MPP had entered into a joint venture to identify properties to run as children's care homes. After two failed efforts that had lost it about £180,000, the parties agreed to put a charge on a house for that amount, to be removed if the care home actually opened. The draft charge, on the standard CH1 form, was the first draft MPP asked the solicitor to check.
Panel 9 of the draft read "2nd Charge of £180,000 payable within 24 months of the date of this agreement". Ms Alberici removed the words "2nd Charge of £180,000" and did not replace them. The judge said that, as a result, there was nothing in the executed charge stating whether any sums were secured, or what they were.
Ratio Law admitted the error was a breach of duty, describing it as "a simple human error". When the parties fell out, the other party pleaded that the charge was void for uncertainty. MPP, advised by new solicitors and counsel, accepted that this defence "was, realistically, unanswerable" and agreed at mediation to cancel registration of the charge. The claim then went to trial on the scope of the duty, the link between the duty and the loss, and the assessment of loss of chance.
What it means for the reader
The facts are ordinary. The firm was asked to check a draft, and an edit removed the text that stated the secured sum. According to Legal Futures, the judge's impression was that Ms Alberici was doing the bare minimum to keep an existing client happy, and that she "read and amended the draft so quickly and so carelessly" that she did not spot the deletion.
For a firm, the lesson is about process rather than personalities. Exposure can arise from a single deletion that nobody noticed. The judge also found Ms Alberici "an unimpressive witness", partly because of what he described as her lack of concern about whether her witness statement was correct. The report does not describe how the firm's internal checks were organised, so it would be wrong to draw conclusions about its supervision arrangements beyond what the judge recorded.
Practical questions follow for any team that edits documents under time pressure. Is there a step after amendment where someone reads the final text against the instructions? Does the person who made the change read it again, or does someone else? Are standard forms checked panel by panel, including the panels that were not expected to change?
Where Counsel AI fits
Counsel AI is software, not a law firm, and it does not remove the need for a fee-earner to read and take responsibility for what goes out. Counsel AI's drafts and first reads cite the section of legislation they rely on, so the person checking can see the basis for a point and test it, rather than taking it on trust. The solicitor still reads and checks the final version.
Questions
What did the court find against Ratio Law?
According to Legal Futures, Ratio Law admitted a breach of duty after a partner deleted the secured sum from a draft legal charge, and was ordered to pay £100,000 plus interest.
Did the firm admit the mistake?
Yes. Ratio Law admitted that a simple human error by its co-founder was a breach of duty, and the trial dealt with the scope of the duty, the link between the duty and the loss, and loss of chance.
Does Counsel AI check documents for the solicitor?
Counsel AI's drafts and first reads cite the section of legislation they rely on, which gives the reviewer something to test. The solicitor still reads and takes responsibility for the final document.
Sources
- Court finds law firm negligent over “simple human error” · legalfutures.co.uk, 9 Nov 2026
- Counsel AI: /, read 10 Nov 2026
Run a free check, or try every workflow for 14 days
Start